NYC Musician Claims Airline Workers Destroyed His Vintage Banjo Case Despite Promising Careful Handling

A New York City musician is accusing TAP Air Portugal of mishandling his century-old banjo after airline workers allegedly damaged its original vintage case during his return flight from the UK.

By Brant.One Newsroom and Crisnel Longino

4 min. read

A New York City musician has accused TAP Air Portugal of mishandling his century-old banjo after airline workers allegedly damaged its original case during his return flight from the UK, according to a report by the New York Post.

David Fryer, 38, said the airline required him to gate-check his 1925 Lange plectrum banjo despite his insistence that the instrument could fit in the overhead compartment. He claimed staff assured him it would be handled carefully, but he found its vintage case severely damaged when he arrived in Newark.

Fryer had travelled to the UK earlier in November for performances in London and Bristol, including an appearance at the 2026 London Antifolk Festival. During the first leg of his journey with TAP Air Portugal, he was able to keep the banjo in its original case inside the aircraft cabin.

However, the arrangements changed during his return journey aboard flight EP1329 from Gatwick to Newark. According to Fryer, crew members instructed him to hand over the instrument at the gate, despite his concerns about its age and condition. Fryer described the instrument as particularly rare and personally irreplaceable, adding that he had explicitly warned airline staff about the care it required.

Musician Finds Vintage Banjo Case Falling Apart After Flight

The musician said he became concerned after hearing a loud impact shortly before baggage workers returned his instrument following a layover in Porto. When the banjo was brought out, Fryer claimed its original hard-shell case was already falling apart, with its top, bottom and sides separating.

He also identified damage to the metal studs underneath the case, which are designed to keep it stable when placed on the ground. One of the studs had reportedly been pushed inward, leaving the bottom damaged as well. Fryer subsequently shared photographs of the broken case on social media, describing the experience as “horrific.”

He also claimed that airline workers offered neither an apology nor compensation after the incident. The musician said he submitted an online complaint to the airline.

David Fryer Warns Musicians About Travelling With Instruments

Fryer expressed frustration over the alleged mishandling, arguing that airline staff had disregarded his warnings about the instrument’s age.

The musician added that comparable banjos can sell for as much as $3,500 on the secondary market, although he considers his own instrument priceless. Known professionally as Urban Orangutan, Fryer performs around New York City and also plays with blues band Hyllus & the Veligers.

Following the incident, he warned other musicians against trusting the airline with valuable instruments, particularly when staff insist on gate-checking items that passengers believe can safely remain in the cabin. He also questioned the assurances given to passengers when airlines promise that delicate equipment will receive special handling.

Vintage Banjo Remains Playable as Musician Awaits Airline Response

Despite the damage to its original case, Fryer said his century-old banjo remained playable after the journey. However, he acknowledged that it was too early to determine whether the impact had caused problems that might emerge later.

“Time will tell,” he said, expressing concern that the force of the impact could eventually affect the instrument.

Advertisement

TAP Air Portugal had not immediately responded to a request for comment at the time of publication.

The incident has also drawn attention to the limitations of protections available to musicians travelling with their instruments. A US law enacted in 2015 requires domestic airlines to allow small musical instruments, including certain stringed instruments, in aircraft cabins when they meet applicable requirements.

Fryer’s complaint follows other reported disputes involving airlines and damaged musical equipment. Earlier in 2026, a baggage handler at Los Angeles International Airport was caught on camera tossing guitars around on the tarmac.

In 2024, singer Madi Diaz also accused Delta Air Lines of intentionally smashing her guitar, prompting the carrier to apologise.

What’s Next

Fryer said his 1925 Lange plectrum banjo remains playable, although he is concerned that the impact could cause problems over time. He has filed a complaint with TAP Air Portugal and claims the airline has yet to offer an apology or compensation.

The carrier had not immediately responded to a request for comment at the time of publication. The outcome of his complaint and whether the instrument develops further damage remain unclear.

Why It Matters

The incident highlights the concerns musicians face when travelling with valuable or irreplaceable instruments, particularly when airlines require passengers to surrender them for checked baggage.

Although some US regulations protect musicians travelling domestically with small instruments, those protections do not automatically extend to international journeys. For performers carrying vintage equipment, damage can involve more than financial loss, especially when an instrument has historical or sentimental value.

About This Story

Daily Reports is Brant.One's news roundup. Each day we gather the New Mexico stories worth knowing from newsrooms across the state, sum them up and point you to the source. This one comes from New York Post's reporting, and their original story has the interviews and full details. The original story was reported by Jesse O’Neill.

Got a News Tip?

Know about something happening in your New Mexico community? Send it to our newsroom. You can send it anonymously.

Send a Tip

Related Posts

Advertisement

Sponsored Links

Ads by Google